Critique on Fat and Happy Essay - 875 Words

Savannah Masters Mrs. Williamson W131 23 September, 2014 Fat and Happy? Critique In the article â€Å"Fat and Happy?†, Hillel Schwartz questions why society views fat people as pathetic and unacceptable. He argues that if it were not for â€Å"fellow citizens† (179) mocking and scorning them for being fat, they would be perfectly content with themselves. As well as stating that many people discriminate toward fat people, Schwartz also points out that physicians are giving facts about obesity that are deceptive. Although Schwartz has a strong claim regarding acceptance of the overweight, the absence of support and the lack of writing techniques used in his article defeat the purpose of his argument. Schwartz goes in depth with how society†¦show more content†¦Therefore, this argument is unrealistic and does not break the cycle unless society stops judging altogether. Schwartz proceeds to write an argument about the habit of dieting and how it can affect one’s body. He states that losing and gaining weight rep eatedly can make people become fatter than they originally were (180). Since Schwartz does not have reasonable evidence and fails to include a necessary amount of quotes or statistics on the rate of failed diets, his argument cannot be considered reasonable. Schwarts also claims that dieting resembles a form of cannibalism as a result of eating your own body fat (185). Dieting restricts oneself to eat a certain kind or amount of food. Dieting is not equivalent to starving oneself, or as Schwartz refers to as â€Å"eating your own body fat† (185), thus, this statement is illogical. Along with Schwartz frowning upon dieting, he also believes the world should be a fat place. He believes children will be fed well, not one person will feel self-conscious, and children will not struggle with eating disorders (183). Although Schwartz makes some valid points, Schwartz becomes stereotypical with his â€Å"fantasy†. â€Å"People will wear horizontal stripes and bold colors† is one of the examples of being stereotypical. Fat people do not retain themselves from wearing a design just because it makes them look more wide, but because they simply do not like the pattern (184). WhenShow MoreRelatedCritique Of Fat And Happy917 Words   |  4 PagesCritique of â€Å"Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat Acceptance† The pressure to lose weight in today’s society constrains the personality and health of overweight people while essentially increasing the weight of those who experience these pressures (Worley 163-167). So reasons Mary Ray Worley in her article, â€Å"Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat Acceptance.† Using personal experiences as well as a small number of facts, Worley disputes the reason overweight people struggle as they attempt to contribute toRead MoreCritique of Mary Worleys Article: Fat and Happy Essay997 Words   |  4 Pagesoverwhelming from media and doctors. Mary Ray Worley, a member of the National Association to Advance Fat Acceptance (NAAFA), believes that modern day society is completely intolerant of obesity so much as to say that they would rather die or cut off a limb than be fat (492). She has made it a priority to convince Americans to accept obesity which she fights for in her essay, Fat and Happy: In Defense of Fat Acceptance. She believes that peop le should not be ashamed of their bodies, or try to change themRead MoreAnalysis Of Sartre s The Wall870 Words   |  4 Pagesthe story is about the last night of 3 prisoners awaiting their death sentence. The short story does not focus on the details of the War, instead it deeply examines the most fundament element and result of the War: death. Consequently, Sartre’s critique of the nature of the universe and nature of man is viewed through the lens of one who is anticipating death. In The Wall Sartre makes an indirect comment about happiness by depicting the void of happiness that can reside in the anticipation of deathRead MoreProposal for Research on Fast Foods Essay912 Words   |  4 Pagespounds more than they should. Schlosser comments that No other nation in history has gotten so fat so fast. In simple terms, Schlosser argues, when people eat more and move less, they get fat. In North America, people have become increasingly sedentary and consume more restaurant m eals, including fast food. As people eat more food outside the home, they consume more calories, less fiber, and more fat. We propose some changes in the fast food industry to reduce rates of obesity and improve overallRead MoreExample Art Gallery Report Essay776 Words   |  4 PagesEXAMPLE ART GALLERY REPORT! Portrait 1 My first portrait I am going to going to critique is a oil on canvas piece by Scott Jones B. This first portrait I am going to critique is called going on four. The first thing you immediately see about the piece is the scantily clad cartoonish bee looking character set in the foreground .The piece is of a bee looking character set in the middle of theRead More`` Barbie Doll `` By Marge Percy905 Words   |  4 Pagesundergo plastic surgery to fix her â€Å"big nose† and â€Å"fat legs†. Unfortunately she ended up dying in her struggle to meet the standard that the media has placed on her at an exceptionally young age. Her untimely death is a symbol and the theme of the poem that these women will work themselves to death to meet societies demands and most of the time it is all for nothing. All this women wanted was people to accept the way she looked and not critiqu e her looks and it was not until her funeral day, whenRead MoreFight Club By David Fincher1041 Words   |  5 Pagesand perfection. As he became a slave of common franchises around him, the narrator strived to get it all. However, no matter how many things he bought, never had he achieved the definition of satisfaction. People rely on profit and possessions to be happy, but does it really help? Fight Club carries philosophical messages about money and materialism to the capitalist society in order to wake up and realize that those objects are not the key to happiness. Once the narrator bought one item from the IKEARead MoreEthical Theories And Principles Of The Ethics1576 Words   |  7 Pagesand if this produces an impossible world or some kind of contradiction then our action is wrong. The first question is that stems from the first step is, â€Å"What would happen if everyone did this?† Essentially, an action is right if you would still be happy if everyone else in the world did this. To better understand, here are a few examples of this premise. When deciding whether or not it is morally correct to lie one would go through a thought process similar to the following: We should not lie becauseRead MoreA Rose for Emily by William Faulkner1250 Words   |  5 Pagescrafting the characters in the story, Faulkner is able to critique the typical southern view of African-Americans as well as demonstrate the unwillingness of the older generations to transform their rules and ideals to match the change of society that came with the younger gene ration. Throughout the story, Faulkner uses stereotypical behaviors present in Southern culture, such as class structure and racism, in order to demonstrate and critique the prejudice occurring in Southern society. From the veryRead MoreThe Effects Of Media On The Media1466 Words   |  6 Pagescome from letting advertisements guide one’s judgement, sometimes false advertisements can have a negative impact on how a woman perceives herself. People in charge of commercials, magazines, and other ads distort their publications in ways that critique someone’s physical appearance, otherwise known as body shaming. The body shaming done by the media today can lead a woman to not only a mental illness or an eating disorder, but can also lead to a sense of body dissatisfaction. Though many women